QUOTE(nomarfan1997 @ Aug 22 2006, 01:10 PM) [snapback]576747[/snapback]
This team shouldn't be worried about arbitration status with these players.
Every team in the majors should be worried about arbitration status. Every financial decision a team makes has an impact on how much money will be available for player salaries. When dealing with a young player, I'd like to see a FO weigh the following:
1. How much will the guy help the Major League club?
2. How will this impact his development?
3. How much will it cost us, now and in the future.
For #1, Dustin is certainly the best option for this roster spot. In fact, I'd personally rate him as the best option to start at short, but I've been over that. As a backup MI, he won't help the team all that much; as a starter I think he'd help a bit.
For #2, well, he's ready. And with minor league ball ending soon, he is going to come up. He needs the seasoning, and he's likely to learn a lot from playing in the majors. No problem here.
For #3, it comes down to whether it's going to bring his free agency on one year early. I don't think it will, but it COULD. Let's say it DOES start his clock one year early... we're trading one year of "Dustin in 6 years" for 1 year of "Dustin now." Is that worth the benefits outlined above? Consider that "Dustin in 6 years" will probably be at his career best, while now he'll likely be at his career worst (unless he hangs on too long).
That's for the baseball people to decide. But if they're NOT weighing these decisions, they're shirking their duties to do the best possible for the Sox. For example, Bonderman looks all well and good now, but if the Tigers had kept him in the minors 2 more years they'd have him locked up 'til he's in his late 20s. I guarantee you in 3 years when he bolts for New York they'll wish they had him locked up for 2 more years... but they won't, because of a decision they made back in '03. Considering the things I outlined above, this decision probably wasn't too smart. #1, he didn't help the team all that much when he was putting up a 5.5 ERA for a team going nowhere. #2, he developed fine, but could very well have done so in the minors as well. All in all, there was no reason to bring him up, and it's going to hurt them in a couple of years.
Anyway, I like Dustin on the big club now, as I've made obvious in the past. He can help us, thus he'll be worth the cost down the line.