Slightly off topic, but within the confines of talking about ARod and Boras:
Someone over at SoSH posted the link
http://youbeenblinded.com/wp-content/uploa...d-hp-binder.pdf to a PDF file of the Prospectus issued in 2000 by Scott Boras when Alex Rodriguez was seeking the fame and fortune he wasn't about to find as a Seattle Mariner.
I've always been saying it was 50 pages. I guess I was wrong; Boras managed to pad it out to 73 pages...wow.
I got a kick out of Page 11, where Boras brags rather speciously that
"compared to HOF shortstops, Rodriguez towers above the field in HRs at age 24".Right. Since ARod started his MLB career at age 18, he had 6+ years in the majors (7 calendar years) by age 24, hitting in the HR-friendly Kingdome for most of that time.
The next name down on Boras' list -- Ernie Banks -- has only 65 HRs by age 24. But he was a rookie at age 22. If you look at Banks' first 7 years, he has 228 HRs. (great comparison, Boras!)
If the next guy, Travis Jackson, had any power at all it was eaten up by the Polo Grounds, unless he managed to hit either to extreme LF or extreme RF. He also was a rookie at 18, but understandably logged only 60 HRs in 7 seasons. (equally "interesting" comparison)
Robin Yount is listed 4th, and he performed in a pitcher-friendly ballpark his 1st 7 years, one in which a stalwart like George Scott topped the club with 20 and 24 HRs in the 72-73 seasons. Yount hit a total of 57 HRs in 7 years, and is described as "a scrawny shortstop" who didn't develop a line-drive stroke until that 7th year. (this comparison is even more laughable)
Going through the "HOF Shortstops, RBIs" and "HOF Shortstops, SLG%" lists, one can easily poke holes in those comparisons too, where Boras mixes multiple leagues, eras, and ballpark factors without distinction.
No wonder even then-Mets GM Steve Phillips laughed at Boras and this prospectus back in 2000...