Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Manny (could be) traded to Marlins
Royal Rooters > WE'RE TALKIN' BASEBALL > RED SOX - ON THE FIELD
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9
Curll
Sean McAdams is reporting that the Sox have almost completed a deal for Manny to an unnamed NL team.

Gammons, on ESPNnews, said Manny to the Marlins for Hermida and Prospects.

Sportscenter reporting Sox on the "verge" of trading Manny.

http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/blog/index?..._trade_deadline
--------------------------------------------

Latest News Reports: 9:00 AM, 7/31

http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/blog/index?...trade_deadline
czar
QUOTE
With less than 24 hours before the trade deadline, the Red Sox are engaged in serious conversations to trade Manny Ramirez to the Florida Marlins, as well as other teams. If the Red Sox make a deal with the Marlins, it is likely they would kick in money to offset Ramirez's salary, and they would look for three young players in return -- perhaps outfielder Jeremy Hermida or outfielder Josh Willingham, plus pitchers.

The Red Sox have gone down this road many times before with Ramirez, seriously discussing a deal before pulling back -- but what might be different this time is that Ramirez apparently has just two months of regular season with the Red Sox, and Boston could be asking the internal question of how invested Ramirez will be in the last days of the year.


Olney
SFFM38
If Manny Ramirez name is not in the lineup for tonight game then that could give a huge hint of being traded.
ARZJake
Nomar Revisited?

It's time.

Last night proved it by not running full steam on the DP ball.

Great Player, Great History here in Boston. It's time.
Thanks for the Championships Manny, You were a great Player here.
Good luck!
Kylyk
Let's not start saying our goodbyes yet. He never has run out ground balls and I doubt that was the straw that broke the camels back with the FO. It's been this close before and nothing has happened.
CTLovesTheSox
QUOTE(Kylyk @ Jul 30 2008, 06:21 PM) *
Let's not start saying our goodbyes yet. He never has run out ground balls and I doubt that was the straw that broke the camels back with the FO. It's been this close before and nothing has happened.


Yea, let's not forget 3 years ago, when it was the 3 team deal with Tampa and the Mets, and we heard for a day or 2 the sox were set to acquire Crawford, Huff and prospects. Until there's an actual deal I'm not gonna listen to any of this. Just another chapter in the Manny saga for now.
acr
Olney was just on sportscenter and said it's still only a 40% chance that Manny is dealt...he says NL execs have told him that the Sox are actively searching to dump him, and they want him gone.
Todd Lazarchick
i think we need to get maybin or miller from florida to pull this deal, what do u all think?
Curll
QUOTE(CTLovesTheSox @ Jul 30 2008, 06:25 PM) *
Yea, let's not forget 3 years ago, when it was the 3 team deal with Tampa and the Mets, and the sox had all but acquired Crawford, Huff and prospects. Until there's an actual deal I'm not gonna listen to any of this. Just another chapter in the Manny saga for now.


Buh?!

Crawford was not in that deal at all.
CTLovesTheSox
QUOTE(Curll @ Jul 30 2008, 06:27 PM) *
Buh?!

Crawford was not in that deal at all.


I could of swore he was part of it. Perhaps I'm wrong. It's happened before, like twice.
thanman2
It was a three team trade, with the Sox landing Huff and Mike Cameron, not Carl Crawford.
czeckswing
If Manny is gone I think it will be because so many Sox fans wrote him a blank check for 85% effort. Manny is a victim of his own devices enabled by those who failed to require him to grow up.
Lesbian BoyFriend
QUOTE(Todd Lazarchick @ Jul 30 2008, 06:26 PM) *
i think we need to get maybin or miller from florida to pull this deal, what do u all think?

No way they get Maybin in a deal from Florida without throwing in a Buchholz/Ellsbury type player. Maybin has 5 tool potential.
TreeRol
QUOTE(czeckswing @ Jul 30 2008, 06:33 PM) *
If Manny is gone I think it will be because so many Sox fans wrote him a blank check for 85% effort. Manny is a victim of his own devices enabled by those who failed to require him to grow up.


This is just incomprehensibly dumb. I've tried to make sense of it and I just... can't. At all.

I hope we keep him just to piss you off.
acr
Half the rumors have Allison in this...but if we're trading Manny because he's a headcase you can't rely on, why would you ask for a Heroin addict in return?
happymeal88
Hermida is a very, very good prospect. With all the strikes against him (little time in AA and zero time in AAA, playing in the definition of a hitters park in the middle of a horrible batting order) he is still only 24 years old and was one of the highest rated prospects in baseball for a few years. Package him with a couple of good pitchers and I might be ok with dealing a sure-fire, first ballot Hall of Famer away in the middle of a pennant race.

That being said one of the names being bounced around on ESPN News is Jeffery Allison which is a mistake, I think. I mean I am rooting for the kid because of his local ties but it is really smart to bring back a kid who basically spent about a million dollars on using drugs in the Peabody area? I mean he gets sent home from the Marlins for drugs and then spends about a year in Peabody playing wiffle ball and doing more drugs and you want to bring him back to the area? No thanks.

rslogosmall.gif
chicowalker
QUOTE(happymeal88 @ Jul 30 2008, 03:45 PM) *
.....That being said one of the names being bounced around on ESPN News is Jeffery Allison which is a mistake, if I think. I mean I am rooting for the kid because of his local ties but it is really smart to bring back a kid who basically spent about a million dollars on using drugs in the Peabody area? I mean he gets sent home from the Marlins for drugs and then spends about a year in Peabody playing wiffle ball and doing more drugs and you want to bring him back to the area? No thanks.

rslogosmall.gif


maybe Theo was inspired by the Josh Hamilton story wink.gif
alskor
QUOTE(happymeal88 @ Jul 30 2008, 06:45 PM) *
Hermida is a very, very good prospect. With all the strikes against him (little time in AA and zero time in AAA, playing in the definition of a hitters park in the middle of a horrible batting order) he is still only 24 years old and was one of the highest rated prospects in baseball for a few years. Package him with a couple of good pitchers and I might be ok with dealing a sure-fire, first ballot Hall of Famer away in the middle of a pennant race.

That being said one of the names being bounced around on ESPN News is Jeffery Allison which is a mistake, if I think. I mean I am rooting for the kid because of his local ties but it is really smart to bring back a kid who basically spent about a million dollars on using drugs in the Peabody area? I mean he gets sent home from the Marlins for drugs and then spends about a year in Peabody playing wiffle ball and doing more drugs and you want to bring him back to the area? No thanks.

rslogosmall.gif

It cant be true. Besides the other crap, he's a 23 year old pitching in the low minors. He's not even a prospect, really. If he is in the deal, it will be as a throw in, not as any kind of piece. He was a first round talent... but I mean, he's not even doing all that well in High A right now. When viewed in light of ARL, he's nothing at all.

Its got to be other young players, not Allison. Throw that out as a media invention.
happymeal88
Ellsbury
Pedroia
Drew
Ortiz
Youkilis
Lowell
Hermida
Lowrie
Varitek

I mean, it's not the 27 Yankees but that's a pretty good lineup to run out there every night. We all saw the show that JD Drew put on when he batted third with Ortiz out and Youkilis could do a good job of protecting Ortiz.

rslogosmall.gif
alskor
QUOTE
Manny looks headed to Miami

by John Perrotto

Multipe baseball sources say the Red Sox are on the verge of sending disgrunted left fielder Manny Ramirez to the Marlins in a trade for a package of three players that included low Class A Greensboro outfielder Mike Stanton, an 18-year-old who is hitting .275/.351/.569 with 26 home runs in 96 games.


http://www.baseballprospectus.com/unfiltered/?p=965
acr
QUOTE(happymeal88 @ Jul 30 2008, 06:56 PM) *
Ellsbury
Pedroia
Drew
Ortiz
Youkilis
Lowell
Hermida
Lowrie
Varitek

I mean, it's not the 27 Yankees but that's a pretty good lineup to run out there every night. We all saw the show that JD Drew put on when he batted third with Ortiz out and Youkilis could do a good job of protecting Ortiz.

rslogosmall.gif


Any half-decent LHP would shut them down. It wouldn't be pretty.
W.A. Cummings
QUOTE(SFFM38 @ Jul 30 2008, 06:11 PM) *
If Manny Ramirez name is not in the lineup for tonight game then that could give a huge hint of being traded.


Have they removed Manny from the redsox.com banner!?
acr
Looks like Manny's still in the starting lineup.
Caspir
QUOTE(happymeal88 @ Jul 30 2008, 06:45 PM) *
That being said one of the names being bounced around on ESPN News is Jeffery Allison which is a mistake, I think. I mean I am rooting for the kid because of his local ties but it is really smart to bring back a kid who basically spent about a million dollars on using drugs in the Peabody area? I mean he gets sent home from the Marlins for drugs and then spends about a year in Peabody playing wiffle ball and doing more drugs and you want to bring him back to the area? No thanks.


Few things. He's a mL pitcher so he will be in a mL city, not Boston. He's in A ball right now, and unimpressive. Also, most of his bonus money went to doing drugs in the Miami area. He used his family and friends to get high in Peabody.

That stuff is irrelevant anyway. What's important is that he is not a good pitcher. I think someone just included his name because he happens to be from Boston.
acr
John Perrotto from Baseball Prospectus is speculating that Mike Stanton(OF Prospect, not dinosaur RP) would be involved in the deal.
alskor
Stanton has been RIDICULOUS, btw:

CODE

Team League AVG G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI TB BB SO SB CS OBP SLG OPS
GBO SAL .275 96 360 62 99 24 2 26 65 205 33 120 4 2 .351 .569 .920



2nd round pick. 18 years old.

EDIT: He wasnt ranked that highly by most sources entering the season - he was seen as a raw, toolsy athlete. This production set him up for a huge jump, though.
happymeal88
QUOTE(Caspir @ Jul 30 2008, 07:01 PM) *
Few things. He's a mL pitcher so he will be in a mL city, not Boston.
Last time I checked Pawtucket, Lowell and Portland are all within driving distance of Peabody...


I like the idea Stanton coming back, even though he is a long way off, but not if it means that we don't get Hermida or Willingham from the Marlins. I'd rather take the established, talented major leaguer and a lesser prospect than the inverse. If we do get Hermida and Stanton, that outweighs what Atlanta got for Texeria so I will be a happy camper (which is obvously the benchmark trade for the deadline so far).
QUOTE(alskor @ Jul 30 2008, 07:06 PM) *
EDIT: He wasnt ranked that highly by most sources entering the season - he was seen as a raw, toolsy athlete. This production set him up for a huge jump, though.
Idk about that -- Florida has a really strong minor league system and he almost cracked their Top 10 prospect list before the season and was given the title of best athlete and most power in the organization by Baseball America. And when you're considered a better athlete than Maybin -- well, that's saying something.

rslogosmall.gif
alskor
QUOTE
A highly-placed Phillies source has shot down speculation that they will acquire Manny Ramirez from the Red Sox for Pat Burrell in an exchange of left fielders, saying "that is not going to happen and was never going to happen." If the Red Sox do find a taker for Ramirez, they may make a late run at Pirates outfielder Jason Bay, if they're not beaten to the punch by the Rays. The Red Sox have the type of high-ceiling prospects the Pirates want to restock a bare farm system.


http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=7881
Caspir
QUOTE(happymeal88 @ Jul 30 2008, 07:09 PM) *
Last time I checked Pawtucket, Lowell and Portland are all within driving distance of Peabody...

I like the idea Stanton coming back, even though he is a long way off, but not if it means that we don't get Hermida or Willingham from the Marlins. I'd rather take the established, talented major leaguer and a lesser prospect than the inverse. If we do get Hermida and Stanton, that outweighs what Atlanta got for Texeria so I will be a happy camper (which is obvously the benchmark trade for the deadline so far).

rslogosmall.gif


So a pitcher with an ERA above 4.50 in A ball is suddenly going to be placed in AA or AAA if he gets sent to Boston? Seriously? I think he'd be in Greenville if anything. And since he isn't a good baseball player now that he's dope free, it's still irrelevant. I'm definitely not gonna get dragged into a tard fight over a non prospect like Jeff Allison.

Anyone who wants 29 year old Josh Willingham and his back problems for Manny is just insane. I'd love to get Hermida and prospects though.
chicowalker
QUOTE(alskor @ Jul 30 2008, 04:06 PM) *
Stanton has been RIDICULOUS, btw:
...


Looks like #s approaching Manny's -- except for the Ks and walks... and it being A ball. smile.gif
alskor
QUOTE(happymeal88 @ Jul 30 2008, 07:11 PM) *
Idk about that -- Florida has a really strong minor league system and he almost cracked their Top 10 prospect list before the season and was given the title of best athlete and most power in the organization by Baseball America. And when you're considered a better athlete than Maybin -- well, that's saying something.

rslogosmall.gif

Sickels had him as the 20th best Marlins prospect going into this season. He explained that he was too raw to be ranked higher.

Here's some more stuff, just general, not in response to you:

QUOTE
Mike Stanton, OF, Low-A Greensboro (Marlins)
A second-round pick last year out of a California high school, Stanton looked very raw in his 2007 pro debut, going 9-for-56 with 21 strikeouts. A player who backs up his 6'5" frame with outstanding athleticism, Stanton has undergone one of the biggest breakouts in the minors the year, going deep Friday and Saturday to give him 18 home runs in 265 at-bats and an overall line of .291/.349/.581. There are still some huge steps that need to be made in Stanton’s approach, as he’s struck out 90 times so far while drawing just 16 unintentional walks, but this kind of production, especially on the power side, from an 18-year-old in a full-season league is very special, and Stanton’s prospect status is going through the roof.


http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=7704

KG at BP didnt have him in the team's top 11, either, so there's no write up, unfortunately.

QUOTE(chicowalker @ Jul 30 2008, 07:16 PM) *
Looks like #s approaching Manny's -- except for the Ks and walks... and it being A ball. smile.gif

Well, for a very toolsy 18 year old in A ball, that's extremely impressive.

EDIT: This guy has crazy raw power - something we're always desperate for. Him and Hermida would be a nice return, IMHO. If the rumblings that a pitcher is coming too are true, that would be great. Id be delighted with that deal. We'd still have a great chance to get hot and win this year and we would be twice as well positioned going forward. I say do it.
alskor
QUOTE
Manny in three-way deal that includes Marlins, Pirates?

A new wrinkle has been added to the Manny Ramirez to Marlins' scenario. A source told MLB.com that a three-way trade may be in the works.

Under this scenario, Ramirez would go to the Marlins, while Jeremy Hermida would go to the Pirates, and Jason Bay would go to the Red Sox.

The Marlins are not afraid to roll the dice and gamble. Team president David Samson, when asked on the team's flagship station, 790 The Ticket, was asked about the Manny Ramirez rumors.

"The Marlins always seem to be in the middle of everything," Samson said. "I don't know how we do that every deadline. We're spending all day trying to figure out a way where we can get better, to stay good, to try to figure out a way how we could win this thing. Everything is possible."


http://trades.mlblogs.com/archives/2008/07...al_that_in.html


-------------------------------------------

Jason Bay
Age 29
OF
Contract: owed $7.5M for 2009

2008: .281/.376/.523 (.899) 22HR 7SB (0 CS)
PECOTA: .266/.364/.485 (.849) 25HR 9SB (2 CS)
Career: .281/.375/.516 (.891) 140HR 50SB (11 CS)

Fielding (last three seasons - 06, 07, 08):

RZR
.867, .842, .862

RF
2.14, 2.02, 1.75

ZR
.839, .828, .807
happymeal88
Not a fan of a straight Manny for Bay swap. The great thing about Hermida is he is only 25 years old.

rslogosmall.gif
alskor
QUOTE(happymeal88 @ Jul 30 2008, 07:32 PM) *
Not a fan of a straight Manny for Bay swap. The great thing about Hermida is he is only 25 years old.

rslogosmall.gif

Well, if people really would rather have the picks than Hermida - youd essentially be getting the closest possible thing to Manny in Bay and then getting the same benefit at the end of the next season if he walks. So you buy a season at a reasonable price.

It also allows you to buy time for Kalish, Reddick, etc... maybe Lars looks ready and Youk goes to LF, etc... it buys you some more time and then you can reevaluate your needs without the pressing problem of Manny, his flare ups and the impending options, etc...


--------------------------------------------------

UH-OH.


QUOTE
The deadline to trade players without going to waivers is Thursday at 4 p.m. ET. As a player with 10 years in the majors and five with the same team, Ramirez has the right to veto any deal. If he waives a trade to a team, he must sign paperwork 24 hours prior to the deal.

"They haven't asked me for anything," Ramirez said told ESPNdeportes.com's Enrique Rojas on the phone from Fenway Park before the Red Sox-Angels matchup on Wednesday night.

"The Red Sox don't deserve a player like me," Ramirez said. "During my years here I've seen how they [the Red Sox] have mistreated other great players when they didn't want them to try to turn the fans against them.

"The Red Sox did the same with guys like Nomar Garciaparra and Pedro Martinez, and now they do the same with me. Their goal is to paint me as the bad guy," Ramirez added. "I love Boston fans, but the Red Sox don't deserve me. I'm not talking about money. Mental peace has no price and I don't have peace here."


Crap on a stick.

http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=3511804
chicowalker
QUOTE(alskor @ Jul 30 2008, 04:16 PM) *
...Well, for a very toolsy 18 year old in A ball, that's extremely impressive.

EDIT: This guy has crazy raw power - something we're always desperate for. Him and Hermida would be a nice return, IMHO. If the rumblings that a pitcher is coming too are true, that would be great. Id be delighted with that deal. We'd still have a great chance to get hot and win this year and we would be twice as well positioned going forward. I say do it.


just giving you a hard time

I'm fine with a deal for Hermida+, though it hurts us this year.
Curll
http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=3511804

Yiiiiiikes
Todd Lazarchick
id rather Bay, he would be the closest thing to manny's production, more then hermedia
SirFozzie
Seeing this quote from the latest ESPN article... if he has signed a waiver of the no-trade, he's gone.


"The Red Sox don't deserve a player like me," Ramirez said. "During my years here I've seen how they [the Red Sox] have mistreated other great players when they didn't want them to try to turn the fans against them.

"The Red Sox did the same with guys like Nomar Garciaparra and Pedro Martinez, and now they do the same with me. Their goal is to paint me as the bad guy," Ramirez added. "I love Boston fans, but the Red Sox don't deserve me. I'm not talking about money. Mental peace has no price and I don't have peace here."
alskor
QUOTE
Details of possible Manny deal

Wednesday, July 30, 2008 | Print Entry

Posted by Jayson Stark
Officials from teams around the sport are now beginning to hear details about the structure of the Manny Ramirez deal. According to one of them, the three players the Red Sox are seeking from the Marlins for Ramirez are Jeremy Hermida, pitcher Ryan Tucker and big-time outfield prospect Mike Stanton. However, the two sides also have discussed substituting Josh Willingham for Hermida.

http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/blog/index?..._trade_deadline


--------------------------------------------

Ryan Tucker
21 years old
Spent most of the year in AA where he put up a line of:

CODE

Team League W L ERA G GS CG SHO SV IP H R ER HR BB SO GO/AO AVG
CAR SOU 4 2 1.38 13 12 0 0 0 72.0 51 12 11 2 28 62 0.90 .194


...but he also has had 34 pretty poor innings in MLB this year.

Sickels graded him a B and had him as the Marlins second best prospect, behind only Maybin.

KG had him as a three star prospect, the 7th best in the system:

QUOTE
7. Ryan Tucker, RHP
DOB: 12/6/86
Height/Weight: 6-2/190
Bats/Throws: R/R
Drafted: 1st round, 2005, Temple City HS (CA)
2007 Stats: 3.71 ERA at High-A (138.1-142-46-104)

Year In Review: The best pure arm in the system continued to frustrate the organization, this time with a so-so showing at High-A Jupiter.
The Good: Tucker gets excellent leg drive and consistently pumps out mid-90s gas, touching 98 at times. He has a remarkably quick arm and a powerful frame that allows his fastball to park at those velocities throughout the game. His command has improved dramatically since signing, and he earns high praise for his makeup.
The Bad: Tucker's secondary offerings still lag well behind his fastball, as his slider tends to flatten out more often than not, and his changeup is rudimentary. Many wonder if he could be far more effective in a bullpen role, believing that he could sit at 97-98 mph if he only had to throw 15-20 pitches per outing.
Fun Fact: Tucker made just eight of his 24 starts at home, but had a 2.13 ERA in those outings.
Perfect World Projection: For now, the Marlins will keep him as a starter, knowing that significant innings are required for Tucker to work on his off-speed pitches. If those come around, he has more potential than many pitchers above him. If not, he's bullpen-bound.
Timetable: Tucker will begin 2008 in the Double-A rotation, and everyone will know more about his future role by the end of the year.


http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=7071


Stanton, Tucker and Hermida would be a nice haul, though it remains to be seen what it would take to get Bay.

EDIT: More on Tucker, from BP's pitchers of the month for April of 08:

QUOTE
Tucker is arguably the story of the Marlins system this year. Part of the bevy of pitching prospects that Florida selected in the 2005 draft, Tucker has always had the best arm strength of any of them, but problems with command, focus, and finding a consistent breaking pitch have kept him from taking the big step forward that his mid-90s velocity readings have always seemed to portend. This might be that year, as Tucker has absolutely dominated this year, pitching shutout baseball in four of his seven starts, never allowing more than two runs in any outing and compiling a 0.89 ERA in 40.1 innings.


http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=7494

He also had Tucker as the 68th best prospect in 2007, though he dropped off the list entering this season.
happymeal88
QUOTE(Todd Lazarchick @ Jul 30 2008, 07:47 PM) *
id rather Bay, he would be the closest thing to manny's production, more then hermedia

He's also 30 years old (5 years older than Hermida) and a free agent after next season, whereas Hermida was the top prospect in a very, very deep and talented Florida organization for from 2004-2006, is 25 years old and cost controlled for three more years.

rslogosmall.gif
The Ghost of Ned Martin
QUOTE(SirFozzie @ Jul 30 2008, 07:50 PM) *
"The Red Sox don't deserve a player like me," Ramirez said. "During my years here I've seen how they [the Red Sox] have mistreated other great players when they didn't want them to try to turn the fans against them.



I'm on record here as believing that Manny's reputation has been damaged as much by his actions as anything the FO or media has put put there. That said, it's hard to argue with Manny's charge the the FO attempts to demonize players they are either not going to sign or plan to trade.

Look at what's happened over the past week and a half. Gammons attacks Manny's character in an ESPN.com piece. Jerry Remy claims that Manny has changed and is not the same guy he once was. Even Tom Caron, who never criticizes a Sox player, said last night that perhaps things have reached the point where Manny's distractions outweigh his production.

Is it a coincidence that suddenly Manny is getting slapped around from all sides of the media? It's hard to imagine that it is.

If the FO thinks it's time to move Manny, I'm fine with that as long as they get appropriate return for him. I don't need them to convince me that Manny is a bad guy. I don't think he his. Most fans don't either. In fact, most fans like Manny and appeciate what he has given this franchise.

I don't need the Red Sox telling me how I should feel.
SoxFanPJ
QUOTE
by Will Carroll

I’m hearing that a multi-team deal involving Jason Bay and the Florida Marlins is in the “final stages.” This could involve the previously in-place dealings involving Manny Ramirez as reported by our own John Perrotto. Joe Frisaro of MLB.com thinks that Bay could end up in Boston, Jeremy Hermida in Pittsburgh, and prospects flying every which way. My sources agree, though I will update as details become clearer.
\\

https://baseballprospectus.com/unfiltered/?p=966
FenwayPride
QUOTE(The Ghost of Ned Martin @ Jul 30 2008, 08:03 PM) *
I'm on record here as believing that Manny's reputation has been damaged as much by his actions as anything the FO or media has put put there. That said, it's hard to argue with Manny's charge the the FO attempts to demonize players they are either not going to sign or plan to trade.

Look at what's happened over the past week and a half. Gammons attacks Manny's character in an ESPN.com piece. Jerry Remy claims that Manny has changed and is not the same guy he once was. Even Tom Caron, who never criticizes a Sox player, said last night that perhaps things have reached the point where Manny's distractions outweigh his production.

Is it a coincidence that suddenly Manny is getting slapped around from all sides of the media? It's hard to imagine that it is.

If the FO thinks it's time to move Manny, I'm fine with that as long as they get appropriate return for him. I don't need them to convince me that Manny is a bad guy. I don't think he his. Most fans don't either. In fact, most fans like Manny and appeciate what he has given this franchise.

I don't need the Red Sox telling me how I should feel.


Or maybe Caron, Remy, and Gammons were just being honest? And maybe Manny has brought this all on himself?

They didn't do this to his image, HE did. He's their player that they have signed, and all he does every year around this time is start mailing it in (usually until after the deadline and he realizes he isn't going anywhere).

The FO didn't hurt Manny's image; Manny hurt Manny's image.
TreeRol
It's funny he mentions Nomar and Pedro. Those are two guys that the Sox got rid of precisely at the right time. And yes, bad stuff came out about them before their departure, but is it possible at all that some of it was warranted? Was Nomar a sulker, Pedro a diva, and Manny a flake? Are those charges that actually have some merit?
TuckSox734
I was guessing it would be a three way with the mets and pittsburg to get Jason Bay here, but hey, not bad right?
alskor
QUOTE(FenwayPride @ Jul 30 2008, 08:08 PM) *
Or maybe Caron, Remy, and Gammons were just being honest? And maybe Manny has brought this all on himself?

They didn't do this to his image, HE did. He's their player that they have signed, and all he does every year around this time is start mailing it in (usually until after the deadline and he realizes he isn't going anywhere).

The FO didn't hurt Manny's image; Manny hurt Manny's image.

Im the first to blame Manny, but its probably a little of both. LL and the Dentist were very concerned with that sort of thing and definitely did that to Nomar.

I dont feel its happening too much here though... a lot of this is just frustration boiling over, IMHO.
FenwayPride
Manny's last AB coming up?

My off-the-wall prediction: Carlos Beltran is our new starting LF by this time tomorrow.

wink.gif
Tyrone Biggums
Im not a fan of conceding the division to Tampa or NY at the deadline. That being said from a pure baseball perspective this deal is logical only if one of two things occur.

1)The Sox make a move in accordance to this (IE, trade a package of players for Jason Bay or Adam Dunn) to supplant Manny's production. This deal is probably heavily influenced by the way the Nomar trade helped the team gel together. The only problem with that scenario is that Nomar was hurt and just didn't play at times. His lack of production was offset by the emergence of Tek Nixon and Ortiz. Thus they could make a deal to improve the defense which was fatally flawed. They still had great hitting, after this deal if it stands as is...not so much.

2)The Sox don't make a move but feel that this would help the long term value of the club in terms of developing their young outfielders and that 3 youngsters are better than 2 draft picks at the end of the year.

Then again...theres a good chance this doesn't happen the team and Manny kisses makes up and wins another WS which is the outcome I know 99.9% of us want to see happen. I've defended Manny for years on this board while I did trash Lowe, but I think this team still could win it all. I understand this isnt the Manny of a few years ago but the guy is still in terms of pure talent a top 10 hitter in the majors.
Naehring Nirvana
QUOTE
That said, it's hard to argue with Manny's charge the the FO attempts to demonize players they are either not going to sign or plan to trade.


Incorrect. It is hard to argue with the fact that the media attempts to "demonize" said players. If the "Manny lovers" are going to dismiss the "Manny haters" charges of lollygagging, clubhouse disturbance, etc based on lack of first hand information, then they also cannot charge the front office with demonizing certain players unless they were in the same room with Shaughnessy, et al when Henry, Epstein, et al were dropping all these malicious quotes slamming Manny. You can't have it both ways.
retire25
QUOTE(FenwayPride @ Jul 30 2008, 08:08 PM) *
Or maybe Caron, Remy, and Gammons were just being honest? And maybe Manny has brought this all on himself?

They didn't do this to his image, HE did. He's their player that they have signed, and all he does every year around this time is start mailing it in (usually until after the deadline and he realizes he isn't going anywhere).

The FO didn't hurt Manny's image; Manny hurt Manny's image.

Actually, you're both right. Manny's conduct here has been indefensible but the FO isn't to be trusted either, in my never-humble opinion. Last weekend, the company line was that they were going to handle it internally, weren't going to comment publicly, etc. Meanwhile, they're leaking out stuff about how they planned to discipline him if he didn't play on Saturday.

And I've always thought the way they treated Nomar on his way out the door was classless. Corporate public relations is about preserving your own reputation even if it means unfairly smearing someone else. The RS are pretty aggressive about it.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.